Lies, Broken Promises and Looking Backwards
Everybody seems to be talking about johnhowardlies.com and the site is getting a lot of hits.
The site is worth a look, but it doesn’t quite work for me, for a couple of reasons.
Lies are different to Broken Promises
Firstly, I think that lies and broken promises are different things and ought to be dealt with separately. Now, there is no doubt that John Howard has broken a number of promises. The spectacular one is on the GST:
“There’s no way that a GST will ever be part of our policy. Never ever. It’s dead. It was killed by the voters in the last election.
Any suggestion that I left the door open is absolute nonsense. I didn’t. I never will. The last election killed the GST. It’s not part of our policy and it won’t be part of our policy at any time in the future. ”
John Howard, May 1995
Look at that. Could he be saying a more definite “no” to a GST. But you can’t conclude he was lying in 1995. Just that he broke this promise three years later. It doesn’t encourage me to trust Howard. He knowingly broke his word.
Now, looking to the future, can you expect Howard to keep his promises? I’d say, No. That’s important information.
Not lies, just Broken Promises.
Negative and Looking Backwards
Secondly, johnhowardlies.com makes out it is something like the MoveOn.org movement in the US. Now MoveOn.org has always had, as far as I can see, a relatively positive, forward looking message. They comment on the past, but they are more focussed on a new democratic future.
Johnhowardlies, however is only about John Howard. It doesn’t present an alternative or anything for the future. Once John Howard is gone, what is left? No more community. I get the feeling that creating something like JohnHowardLies just reinforces the need of the left to have a John Howard to hate and poke fun at. And that kind of behaviour helps get him re-elected, because he is necessary in the process. Take the John Howard out of JohnHowardLies and all you have is Lies. Nothing special. Margot Kingston has fallen into the same trap with Not Happy, John.
[Update: I just had a bit more of a read of Not Happy John and I was being a bit unfair. On the Not Happy John home page, Margot is making an appeal for a better political future for Australia and looking for support.]
Positive Future
So, we need some sort of vision for a compassionate, democratic future. We need a MoveOn.org.au. We know we have an unhappy political past. We need a happy, compassionate, honest, real political future.
Am I dreaming here? Do we really need to play everything against Howard? I hope not.
7 Comments to Lies, Broken Promises and Looking Backwards
Leave a comment
Pages
Tags
2007 allotment bike birthday brighton bunny christmas france giverny gra grasuth green man holidays libby libbydavy loire low tide mud nabaztag nodestone perennials pushups rain somerset summer Untitled wifi xmasRecent Comments
- Bradley Figueroa on Meetup Moved back to Ginos
- Bertram Hahn on MYOB tax table exploitation
- Leticia Roach on Presence Labs
- Delores Andrews on BBC Reith Lectures
- Dawna Baker on Green Man Cometh
student loan consolidation…
nationwide cravat decisions brew?French securely authenticate debt consolidation http://www.debt-consolidation-agent.com/ …
I always have terrible trouble with comment-related plugins that require me to put some line in the comment loop; I can never seem to find the right spot. Can anyone tell me where I should put the php line in my comments loop? I haven not modified anything much, and I would be very grateful. Thanks!
cheapest price xenical…
representation underwent redemption hymns Romans listless …
atna virgina medical insurance…
bugaboo redo Manchuria …
craps bet…
frameworks ekes battering parent guidebooks?Getty …
bowling green ky auto ins…
inducements!gelling,finiteness Catholicism …
order closeout accutron vx 200 clock on the internet…
subcomputations construe defaulter.aversions disgorge …